Canada has many professional sports teams in all the major sports except football. Therefore the functions associated with the Senate are legislative review and the representation of the various regions on a different basis from the lower house. This is a space where subscribers can engage with each other and Globe staff. Representation is selected in favour of the smaller regions, in contrast to the first chamber, where representation is always based on population. If we do not get a triple e senate I fail to see why smaller population wise provinces would want to stay in confederation to be ruled by a majority population wise who has no idea about her unique regional problems. The other major role meant for the Senate was to preserve what MacDonald called sectional interests. The objectives of Senate reform are based on one idea, that of enhancing the quality of regional representation of politicians within national political institutions.
Free essays available online are good but they will not follow the guidelines of your particular writing assignment. Political parties such as the New Democratic Party want the outright abolition of the Senate while others such as the Reform Party want to elect it. As it stands today, the Senate has 104 seats, which are divided into 4 divisions. It was hoped that a Triple-E Senate could provide better representation for Canadians who lived outside of Ontario, Quebec and the Atlantic provinces, and provide a check on the extraordinary powers that our system confers on majority governments. I am all for smaller government but I am also a realist and this is never going to happen so why not try and make our government work better and not just for one or two provinces. When appointing a Senator for Nova Scotia, for example, the Prime Minister would select from a list of nominees supplied by the Government of Nova Scotia.
Political parties such as the New Democratic Party want the outright abolition of the Senate while others such as the Reform Party want to elect it. The organs of government are: Parliament, the executive and the judiciary. In the wake of this failure, the aforementioned Reform Party came to prominence in Alberta, and soon gained considerable political support there. At the same time, in Western Canada, there existed longstanding concerns that federal institutions were primarily oriented towards the interests of Quebec and Ontario, and, as such, were unresponsive to the unique needs and interests of Western Canadians. The Triple E Senate of Canada Public interest in the Senate is currently stronger than it ever has been. However, the way of convincing our prospective customers to purchase on our site is a very tough challenge.
Each of us is qualified to a high level in our area of expertise, and we can write you a fully researched, fully referenced complete original answer to your essay question. The other leading proposal is for the Senate to be abolished outright, which is a position that tends to be favoured by Canadian progressives, particularly those in the New Democratic Party. While Quebec has resisted the Western demand for a 3E Senate, it is possible to imagine a powerful Quebec-Western coalition that seeks to devolve more constitutional authority to the provinces. If this essay isn't quite what you're looking for, why not order your own custom Coursework essay, dissertation or piece of coursework that answers your exact question? In federal systems, the legislative review function of the Senate is only secondary to their role in providing for representation for various parts of the country in the national legislature. Another reason is because the majority of amendments to bills have been introduced to the Senate after it was already approved by the House of Commons. The implementation of a Senate which is elected rather than appointed would ensure that representatives were more responsive to the public.
Therefore, it is extremely important thata means of expression is available to us in our national institutions. The Western Canada region would have been allocated 12 more seats for a new total of 36 , with British Columbia and Alberta receiving four more seats each, and Saskatchewan and Manitoba getting two more seats apiece. Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1963. Since the Senate has not been considered an effective forum for regional representation- which was one of the reasons for its creation-many Canadians have wondered what reforms would allow it to perform that role better. Public interest in the Senate is currently stronger than it ever has been. Another reason for the Senate's past ineffectiveness is due to the fact that Senate appointments are partisan in nature.
This would provide for a new 62 member Senate which would be elected at the same time as Members of Parliament. However, even today, no federal legislation can be passed until it has been passed by majorities in both the Senate and the House of Commons. Unlike Britain, however, Canada lacked an aristocracy, so the Senate quickly became a hotbed of patronage — a place where prime ministers could stick friends and allies as a reward for loyal service. Money poured in, and all seemed well with the world. The weirdness of this system is one of the reasons why the Senate is so controversial. Senators in our Upper House do not really represent anyone except for the one who appointed them-the Prime Minister. It is believed that this agreement about representation in the Senate was the main factor that allowed the Canadian federation to be formed.
The notion, or the concept of having the Senate in Canada is indeed a very powerful one, provided it functioned on the principles of the Triple- E Senate, whereby it would be Equal, Elected, and Effective. The Fathers of Confederation originally intended for the Senate to play the legislative review role. Canadian Senate By: Courtney Marie Lester. However, even today, no federal legislation can be passed until it has been passed by majorities in both the Senate and the House of Commons. When this is the case, the Upper House is seen as a political check on the rule of a simple majority. You can complete the definition of triple e senate given by the English Definition dictionary with other English dictionaries: Wikipedia, Lexilogos, Oxford, Cambridge, Chambers Harrap, Wordreference, Collins Lexibase dictionaries, Merriam Webster. The only exception would be Quebec where Senators would be hand-chosen by the National Assembly.
The Triple-E Senate a for , , and effective is a proposed variation of reform to the current , calling for senators to be elected to exercise effective powers in numbers equally representative of each province; this is in contrast to the present arrangement wherein individuals are appointed to the Senate by the , on the advice of the after which the senators generally do not interfere with the workings of the ; the number of senators allotted to each province is set out in the , and is neither equal nor proportional. Indeed, Western Canada's insistence upon it presents a potentially large opportunity cost. By having the federal government alone appoint Senators and for such long terms until the age of seventy-five , the Senate's ability to represent the regions of Canada has been weakened. However, in the ancient world, this standard of democratic government had not yet taken hold; political control still belonged to the few elite, rich, and powerful persons and influential families. I recognize that devolution is an imperfect substitute for stronger representation at the national level. While china's government appears to be similar as well, but it is quite different.
This was due to the fact that both the Meech Lake and Charlottetown Accords failed to receive the support needed for amending the Constitution. At the time of its creation, the Senate was assigned extensive formal authority and with only two qualifications, it would be equal in power to the House of Commons. We aim to create a safe and valuable space for discussion and debate. Our Senate is a vestige of a bygone era. Across the length and breadth of the country, if there is an opportunity for a festival or an event, you can count on a city, town or village to arrange one. This is particularly clear in the Triple-E Senate movement, as well as reforms proposed under the Charlottetown Accord and by the Conservative government in 2006.
The majority in the Upper House would usually correspond to the majority in the Lower House since appointments were made by the Prime Minister. Presently, the Canadian government is run by Stephen Harper, a man who has been promising to reform the senate, primarily for. Senate Scandals In 2013, Canada was gripped by a high-profile political scandal involving several senators who were alleged to have abused their expense accounts to pay for various frivolous or unjustified things with tax dollars. Any political institution can obtain formal or legal powers, but if the public does not want them to use it, these powers may not be exercised. In the case of Quebec, 24 regions were created in order to have a balance of anglophone and francophone representatives. Reform of the Senate: A Discussion Paper. Past attempts at Senate reform were often included within broader constitutional initiatives the Meech Lake and Charlottetown Accords being two examples.